26 Jan
Just how low will you go? Sure, most of us are willing to nudge the thermostat down a degree or two for the sake of the planet. But living without heat altogether? In Baltimore? A recent New York Times piece, Chilled by Choice, highlights people willing to go to this extreme. Why? Most of the shivering subjects of the article who wear gloves and coats indoors do so out of “thrift, environmentalism, and a commitment to unique real estate.”

Noticeably absent from the people featured were families with babies or young children. In the United States, I’d worry that parents subjecting their children to indoor freezing temperatures would face child abuse charges. But not all countries share our aversion to extreme weather—European youngsters, for example, may enjoy communing with nature in “forest kindergartens,” which are held outdoors rain or shine (or snow).
Before I read this article, I thought I was keeping my thermostat pretty low. Certain guests with weak constitutions have been known to wear their coats inside! For the record, our house is a toasty 64 degrees during the day and a perfectly bearable 55 degrees at night. I’m really not sure I’m capable of living in forty-degree (or colder!) rooms for half of the year, though a part of me wishes I were up to the eco-challenge. What about you?
10 Responses for "A Chilling Proposal: Turn off the Heat!"
We went for 9 days with 40 degree indoor temperatures last winter during the ice storm. Our house was above freezing only due to our kind neighbor lending us his spare generator for a few hours each day. Having experienced that, no, there’s no way I would do it voluntarily. We were all wearing our coats and warm slippers inside, and it was still too cold. Wearing gloves while we tried to read (by window-light) and sleeping with 6 layers of blankets and two pairs of socks was bearable, barely, as a necessity, but not otherwise.
Also… what the heck do these people do about freezing pipes?
I think this is a great idea. Most people’s houses feel unbearably warm to me. Do you really need your house to feel like a Brazilian jungle in the middle of January? I always wonder about people who insist on turning off the light whenever they leave the room but then leave the room a steamy 80 degrees. I live in temperate Portland, so I pretty much only turn on the heat when I have company or during the dead of winter, and even then, it’s just to make my place bearably warm. There is such a thing as a sweater, after all.
Jan, that doesn’t sound like much fun at all. They made it sound almost romantic in the article, though!
Mark, I also find other people’s houses too warm. One of the green advantages of living in an apartment is that it never gets as cold as it is outside. When I lived in an apartment, I turned the heat on just a few times a year. (I also wore gloves and hats inside.)
Oh, and about the freezing pipes: in the article it said they keep their taps dripping all winter.
I can count on one hand how many times I’ve used the heat in our apartment. We get heat from the apartments around us, and Seattle winters are pretty mild, so I think the only time we caved was once when we had a week of 10F temps. Other than that I never even feel the cold, though my parents keep their jackets on.
Having been raised by parents who were always struggling to pay the bills in New England, I am well-acquainted with freezing homes. We actually had a running joke that maybe we’d get heat for Christmas (although, I think they typically had it barely on by Thanksgiving). Quite frankly, this is one area I’m not at all willing to go crazy with. We like to be comfortable in our house, not reaching for coats in the middle of the day. If someone else thinks we live in a sauna, no problem since they don’t actually have to live there. As for how “green” it is or isn’t to keep the heat at where you’re comfortable (and that’s about 72 in daytime, 68 at night, not 80), there are a lot more ways to be environmentally friendly, like weatherstripping, using energy efficient appliances, or cutting down on all the electronic toys that burn so much electricity.
Really, it all comes down to what a person is willing to do. If someone feels good about freezing all the time, more power to them. I think, though, that like the garbage picking people do, I will have to abstain.
Oh, just out of curiosity, with all the water they have to waste keeping the pipes from freezing, does it wash out to be more environmentally friendly or not? I’m guessing it still does, but that seems a big waste of water.
70 to 73 degrees is comfortable for me.
I don’t like wearing a jacket or gloves when I’m at home.
For that, it would have to be pretty cold, too – 50 – 60 degrees. My landlord told me to leave the heater on all winter – not turn it off. He can forget it! I make it comfortably warm – around 71 degrees and then I turn it off.
Okay, who do the people in that article think they’re kidding?
I remember a cold winter in Santiago where central heating was unheard of. If you were lucky, you had a space heater. Some of my Chilean friends who had visited the US believed that central heating caused the breakdown of the american family – everyone in separate rooms. With no central heating you either all want to snuggle, or you heat just one room with a stove or space heater.
So, I lived without heat because we couldn’t afford heat in an old, very drafty house until I was fifteen. We slept several people to a bed and our pipes froze at least once a week. It’s a good thing my dad knew how to fix them. It was awful. We would wear coats, gloves, and hats indoors and sometimes still be cold. We put off showers as long as possible because getting out was awful. I will never, ever do it again.
That being said, now as an adult living in New England, my husband and I keep our heat at fifty-five, the lowest the thermostat in our rental will go, except for the few hours when we’re awake but it’s dark, when we push it up to sixty. At bedtime, it goes back down. I don’t think that’s unreasonable at all.
Leave a reply